Deciding
Sole Proprietorship vs Corporation in Quebec: What the Law Changes for You

As a self-employed person in Quebec, you and your business are the same person in the eyes of the law: your personal assets answer for the debts of the business. A corporation is a separate person that answers for its own debts, and that is where the choice between a sole proprietorship and a corporation is decided. That protection has limits, though, and those limits are what you need to know before choosing.
One clarification right away: this article covers the legal side. Tax and costs also weigh on the decision, and they have to be taken into account.
Key points
- As a sole proprietor, you have only one set of assets. The debts of the business can be collected from your house, your car or your savings.
- A corporation is a separate legal person. A shareholder is not liable for the corporation’s debts: their risk is limited to what they invested.
- That protection has three holes: the personal guarantee your bank will ask you to sign, your own fault, and your duties as a director.
- Government fees are relatively low on both sides: $41 to register a sole proprietorship when registration is required, $397 to incorporate in Quebec.
- The legal side is only one of three criteria, along with tax and costs. It is simply the one people overlook.
Sole proprietorship vs corporation: what is the legal difference?
“Self-employed” describes a tax and social status: you work for yourself, with no employment relationship. It is not the technical name of your legal structure.
The legal structure behind that status is the sole proprietorship. It is not a person separate from you. The business is you.
A corporation, on the other hand, is a legal person. The law recognizes its own existence and its own assets, and its acts bind only itself. When we talk about incorporating, it means creating a corporation.
You will also hear about someone being self-employed and having incorporated. In practice, that person still works for themselves, but it is now their corporation that signs contracts, invoices clients and answers for its debts. The work is still done by the same person, but now it is in the name of the corporation.
So you can run a business your whole life without ever incorporating it. Starting a business and incorporating one are not the same thing.
Who pays the debts of the business?
As a sole proprietor, you answer for the debts of your business with everything you own. The law puts it plainly: whoever commits personally must honour that commitment out of everything they have. Your personal assets and the assets of the business are a single pool, and your creditors can help themselves to it.
Here are a few concrete situations a self-employed person can face:
- An unpaid supplier sues the business, which means they are suing you.
- A commercial lease goes bad. The landlord claims the unpaid rent, and they can claim it from your own assets.
- A client sues you over work done badly. Any judgment will name you personally.
With a corporation, there are two separate sets of assets: the corporation’s, and yours.
If the corporation cannot pay its supplier, its landlord or a judgment, its creditors are paid out of what the corporation owns. They cannot send a bailiff to your home to seize your personal belongings.
Does incorporating really protect your personal assets?
In principle, yes. In practice, not always: three situations are exceptions, and they are well known.
The personal guarantee
This is the most common one. Guaranteeing a debt means committing to pay someone else’s debt if they do not pay it themselves.
A corporation that has just been created has no credit history. So the bank that lends to it, or the landlord who rents it a space, will ask you to guarantee the debt personally. Depending on your bargaining power, that guarantee can sometimes be waived, but you will need solid arguments.
By signing it, you commit personally, and you make your own assets available for that particular debt, despite the incorporation.
It is almost unavoidable at the start: the business has to build its own credit and its own reputation before it can commit on its own.
Your own fault
Incorporating does not protect you from yourself. Everyone remains responsible for the harm they cause through their own fault. If you are the one who caused the damage, being incorporated does not automatically erase your personal liability. There are nuances depending on the situation, but that is the general rule.
Your duties as a director
A person who incorporates alone can wear three hats at once: they are a shareholder, a director, and often an employee of their own corporation. The protection people cite most often when they talk about incorporating is the one that applies to the shareholder, and it does not cover a director’s liability.
In principle, a shareholder is not liable for the acts of the corporation whose shares they hold, and they only risk the amounts they paid for those shares. If you pay $100 for shares in the company, your risk as a shareholder is limited to $100 at most. But if you are a shareholder and also a director, that changes everything.
As a director, the law makes you personally liable along with the corporation in two main situations:
- unpaid wages owed to your employees, up to six months of wages, and subject to certain conditions;
- certain decisions of the board that impoverish the corporation, for example issuing shares in exchange for property or services worth less than their price, or paying a dividend when the law did not allow it. In those cases, you have to pay the corporation back out of your own pocket.
Other statutes, tax statutes in particular, can also make a director personally liable for amounts the corporation failed to remit, for example if it fails to pay its taxes.
The law provides a way out. A director who acted with the care and diligence that was reasonable in the circumstances does not incur liability. That is not a detail: it is exactly why it is worth keeping real resolutions and up to date records.
What we have seen happen with our clients: people incorporate, among other reasons to protect their assets, then sign a personal guarantee for their line of credit or their commercial lease in the weeks that follow. The separation between the two sets of assets still exists, but the largest debt of the business is now shared between them and their corporation. Before signing important contracts, it is always worth having them reviewed by a legal professional.
What does each option cost?
| Sole proprietorship | Corporation | |
|---|---|---|
| To get started | Nothing under your own name, $41 to register under any other name | $397 |
| Every year | $41 if you are registered | $106 |
| Professional fees | None, unless you hire a professional | From a few hundred to more than $1,500 |
A self-employed person does not always have to register. The obligation arises when you carry on business under a name that does not include your surname and your given name. Under your own name, you have nothing to file and nothing to pay (apart from a few exceptional cases).
A corporation is on the register from the day it is created, and it stays there as long as it exists. In fact, it only exists from the moment the Registraire des entreprises issues its certificate of incorporation.
We wrote an article that breaks down the fees you can expect, including professional fees and yearly costs: how much it costs to incorporate in Quebec.
And if you want to see what an incorporation handled by a lawyer on our team includes, it is described on our incorporation page.
What about taxes?
The tax advantages of incorporating are also part of the decision.
This article is not about tax, but it is worth knowing that an accountant can walk you through what incorporating would change for you.
Still, in many cases corporations benefit from a lower tax rate than individuals. There are also business development incentive programs under which some corporations get lower rates still.
It is important to talk to an accountant or a lawyer to understand how your own situation should influence the decision.
Keep in mind too that the tax reasons and the legal reasons to incorporate are weighed together rather than separately.
What legal questions should you ask before choosing?
Here are a few questions that can guide you toward the side the legal argument falls on.
1. Can your work cause harm to someone? Advice, an installation, a product, a worksite, for example. The greater the possible damage, the more the separation between the two sets of assets matters.
2. Are you committing to amounts the business will have to pay later? A lease, a loan or orders from suppliers. And above all, are you about to finance or buy something significant for the business, such as a truck, equipment or premises? A financed purchase is a debt that lives for years, and a corporation can be a good way to take those purchases on.
3. Will you have employees? If you hire them under your sole proprietorship, you will eventually have to transfer them over to your corporation.
4. Are you planning to start the business with partners? As soon as there is more than one of you, the question changes in nature. You will have to decide what kind of arrangement you want. If you choose a corporation, it is worth learning about what a shareholders’ agreement actually does. It is a crucial document for managing the relationship between partners.
Frequently asked questions
Is “sole proprietorship vs incorporation” the same question?
Yes. Incorporating means creating a corporation, so both phrasings describe the same choice: staying a business that is legally you, or putting a separate legal person between you and your work. Be careful with a third word, though. Registering a business is not the same as incorporating one: a sole proprietor registers with the Registraire des entreprises, while only a corporation is incorporated.
Does a self-employed person have to register with the Registraire des entreprises?
Yes, but only if they carry on business under a name that does not include their surname and their given name. Under your own name, registration is not mandatory. A few specific activities require it anyway, such as selling tobacco or operating a tanning salon.
Does a self-employed person have a NEQ?
The NEQ, the Quebec enterprise number, is assigned at registration. A self-employed person who is not registered therefore does not have one.
Does incorporating protect my house?
It protects your personal assets from the debts of the corporation, except in three cases: if you personally guaranteed the debt, if the damage comes from your own fault, or in the situations where your liability as a director is engaged.
Do my GST and QST numbers follow me when I incorporate?
No. Your registration for the GST and QST files belongs to you as a self-employed person, and it does not transfer. The corporation is another person, so it has to register on its own and obtain its own numbers. Plan for that step when you incorporate.
Can you start as a sole proprietor and incorporate later?
Yes, and it is the most common path. Many people start out self-employed for the flexibility and the cost, then incorporate once they are confident the business is working.
In summary
Legal risk is one of the criteria to weigh before incorporating. It is often overlooked in favour of the tax advantages, but it is no less decisive for that.
As a sole proprietor, everything you own answers for the business. Once you have a corporation, there are two separate sets of assets, as long as you do not tie them back together yourself.
Your certificate of incorporation creates a legal entity separate from you. But your personal signature at the bottom of a guarantee could be what changes the picture.
A specific question?
Talk with your lawyer for 15 minutes, today. Free, no obligation.
Talk to a lawyer

